The Bible–What’s True For You?

Innocently enough, I commented on a writers blog posting by a gentleman named Paul, from Boston. Thus began an intense interchange that … well, take a look.

Paul ended his posting with the statement that “most Christians believe that ‘God helps those who help themselves.’”

I couldn’t let that pass. 01/21/12 10:57 AM, I wrote: 

“Paul, I don’t know how many Christians you know but the idea that ‘God helps those who help themselves’ is simply not true. It’s found nowhere in the Bible but is often used–by those inside and outside the faith–to cloak a me-first attitude with the name of deity.”

Within hours, Paul sent this mortar round into my email in-box (emphasis mine):

You missed the point entirely, Samuel, and instead twisted a discussion about truthfulness in job postings for freelance writers to show off your (apparently minimal) knowledge about the Bible. I wan’t (sic) making a theological point. Of course the expression I quoted doesn’t appear in the Bible … That’s Biblical exegesis on a Sunday School level. It’s a colloquial expression, however, the meaning of which is clear and understandable to everyone … Please don’t thump your literalist Bible understanding in my face. If you’d like to debate the Bible or religion generally, try me.

Wow! After I picked myself up off the floor, I debated if I should respond. But I knew that God loves Paul; perhaps this was for him more than for me. I shouldn’t let it pass.  

So three days later, I did respond …
“Paul, I see by your response that I touched a nerve. It wasn’t my purpose to inflame you and for that I apologize.

“… your last sentence—which includes the motto, ‘God helps those who helps themselves’—is problematic for both of us. That unfortunate sentence does several things:

  • The saying is, as you point out, a colloquialism, going back to ancient Greece. It has nothing to do with the blog topic. So why insert it in a discussion about unsalaried work for a Christian organization? Makes you look bad.
  • Many people with little knowledge of scripture tend to attribute the statement to the Bible. Your use of it in the context of the forum undermines your claim of superior biblical knowledge.
  • Your assertion that most Christians believe the old saw is without foundation. Simply not true. Very few Christians actually believe that—even those without a literalist Bible understanding.

“You contend that my mention of one statement not included in scripture is ‘showing off’ my knowledge about the Bible. That’s hard to fathom; I sent my comments to you alone and I’m certainly not trying to impress you. If you feel that pointing out your misused reference was ‘thumping my literalist Bible understanding’ in your face, well, I’m sorry I offended you. You may be right concerning my ‘apparently minimal knowledge about the Bible,’ as every week, it seems, I discover something new from God’s Word.

“Kudos for divining my position on biblical inerrancy. I do, indeed, believe the Bible is literally true, if for no other reason than that it has more scholarly support than any other ancient or religious book.

“Your writing shows passion, the mark of a good writer; however, you undercut your abilities by a tendency to over-react. Your challenge to a religious debate was over the top and would have no place in the forum.

“I wish you the best in your writing.”

Paul responded in both surprising and unexpected fashion two days later. We’ll get to that this week. In the meantime,  what’s your take on the nature of the Bible? Or even on the “God helps those …” motto?


About samuelehall

A follower of Jesus, husband, father of 3 adult children, writer and learner.
This entry was posted in Risking change/changing the risk and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to The Bible–What’s True For You?

  1. Doris Minard says:

    Every ? or maybe most ? promises in God’s Word begin with something we are to do first. Ask and you shall receive; seek and….; knock and…. are examples of many more I found both in the Old and New Testaments. Whether that can be construed to mean we are to help ourselves is another matter. What it does mean to me, is that we are to be proactive as Christians in seeking God’s will, asking for his help in any our concerns, or inviting His presence into our lives.

  2. John Pelkey says:

    Well, at least you are having fun. Communication is a tricky thing. It is interesting and never predictable what pushes people’s buttons. I once got blasted after responding to a columnist. When I asked him why, since I agreed with him, his response was Oops. He hadn’t bothered to read far enough into my response to realize we were in agreement. It is always good when one of the two communicating doesn’t have the need to win. Otherwise, communication turns into noise.

    • samuelehall says:

      Yeah, but at first it wasn’t fun. It felt personal, which is ridiculous. Paul (who appears about my age) is just a hurting guy. He’s apparently had enough religion to inoculate him against all of it.
      And emails are easily misunderstood. Good to have your empathy anyway, John.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s